Virginia Soybean Variety Evaluation Tests 1997

David L. Holshouser, Soybean Specialist, Virginia Tech

H. L. Pulley, Research Specialist, Virginia Tech

Tidewater Agricultural Research and Extension Center
6321 Holland Rd.
Suffolk, Virginia 23437
(757) 657-6450

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Please note: Tables 1 through 13 are also available as an Excel Spreadsheet file.
Acknowledgments Table. 5 Performance of Maturity Group IV-S Entries at Four Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests (see excel spreadsheet)
Introduction to Variety Tests Table. 6 Performance of Maturity Group IV-S Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Double Crop Tests (see excel spreadsheet)
Methods and Definitions Table. 7 Performance of Maturity Group IV Roundup Ready Entries at Four Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests (see excel spreadsheet)
Production Information Table. 8 Performance of Maturity Group IV Roundup Ready Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Double Crop Tests (see excel spreadsheet)
Monthly Precipitation Table. 9 Performance of Maturity Group V Entries at Four Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests (see excel spreadsheet)
Suppliers of Soybean Varieties Table. 10 Performance of Maturity Group V Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Double Crop Tests
Table. 1 Performance of Maturity Group III Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests Table. 11 Performance of Maturity Group V Roundup Ready Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests
Table. 2 Performance of Maturity Group III Roundup Ready Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests Table. 12 Performance of Maturity Group V Roundup Ready Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Double Crop Tests
Table. 3 Performance of Maturity Group IV Entries at Four Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests (see excel spreadsheet) Table. 13 Performance of Maturity Group VI Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Full Season Tests
Table. 4 Performance of Maturity Group IV Entries at Three Virginia Locations, Double Crop Tests 


Acknowledgements

Sincere thanks is given to the many cooperators and contributors who have made the Soybean Variety Evaluation Tests possible.

The cooperation and support offered by commercial seed companies, state crop improvement associations, and several experiment stations in supplying seed and information on varieties is gratefully acknowledged.

Special thanks is given to the following cooperators for supplying land and technical assistance while conducting these tests:

A special note of appreciation is also extended to the Unit Extension Faculty who do an excellent job of disseminating the information.

The authors would also like to express appreciation to Patsy Lewis, Patty Turner, Morris Glover, and Teresa Vaughan for their technical and secretarial assistance. We are also very appreciative to Donna Thomas and the support staff at the USDA Analytical Chemistry Support Unit at Peoria, Illinois for their assistance in determining percent protein and oil. Their assistance in the collection of data and preparation of this report is gratefully acknowledged.

Financial assistance from the Virginia Soybean Board to help fund a portion of these tests is gratefully acknowledged.

Return to Table of Contents


INTRODUCTION TO VARIETY TESTS

The purpose of this publication is to provide performance data of the many soybean varieties offered for sale in Virginia. These data should be of benefit to producers and agribusinesses in making selections of varieties for their use. It is realized that not all varieties which are offered for sale in Virginia are included in these tests. There is no implication that varieties not included are inferior in any way, but only that they have not been tested. The private varieties that have been evaluated in these tests were submitted for testing by commercial seed companies.

Variety evaluations were conducted under full season conditions at Suffolk, Warsaw, Orange, Blackstone, and Painter. Double-crop tests were no-till planted at Suffolk, Warsaw, and Painter. Due to the number of entries, it was necessary to separate the varieties by maturity groups in all locations.

1997 was a very difficult year for Virginia Soybean Producers and we experienced similar circumstances. As shown in Production Information, rainfall was below average during most of the growing season and moisture stress reduced yields. The season began with unseasonable cold weather, resulting in slow and eratic germination. The soybean stands for full-season tests (non-Roundup Ready) at Suffolk were poor and resulted in high variability (CV’s). As a result data for the maturity group V varieties are not presented. After warming up to normal conditions in mid-June, Rainfall was below normal at all locations. Hurricane Danny brought needed relieve to some of the locations with approximately 5 to 6 inches of rain; however, much of this rain ran off and was not necessarily effective. Regardless, this rainfall plus some small, but timely rains in August resulted in relative high full season yields at Orange and Suffolk. The double crop plantings at most locations were delayed due to hot, dry, soil conditions. Virtually no rain fell during the critical periods of crop development in any double-crop test, resulting in low yields. Rainfall did increase substantially during the harvest, therefore many plots were not harvested until late November and December

INTERPRETING THE RESULTS

Tables 1 through 13 contain the results of the 1997 tests and also include two-year mean yields at each location. The highest yielding varieties are listed first in each table. It is not statistically correct to compare varieties from different maturity groups. However, it is recommended that producers select two to three of the highest yielding varieties from each maturity group adapted to his region in order to spread out harvesting time and yield risks associated with timing of summer rainfall patterns. Because of year to year variability in variety performance it is suggested that data for varieties with less than three locations or years testing be considered preliminary. The average performance of a variety over multiple environments is more reliable than its performance in one test. Many of the new varieties, which do not have two-year averages, are excellent and will probably earn a share of the Virginia soybean acreage. Other traits are also shown in the tables (maturity, lodging, height, quality, protein, and oil) because each producer emphasizes certain of these traits or a combination of them when selecting varieties for his farm. After examining these results, the producer may want to plant limited quantities of several new better performing varieties to observe how they perform on his farm and under his management conditions.

Within maturity groups at each location, an LSD (least significant difference) was calculated. The LSD is a statistical test calculated at the 10% probability level to aid the reader in comparing the yield differences among varieties within a particular maturity group. When two entries are compared and the difference between them is greater than the calculated LSD value, the varieties are considered to be significantly different. The "NS" designation indicates that there were no significant differences for yield among the varieties within that maturity group. The coefficient of variation (CV) is a relative measure of variation and is an indicator of the degree of precision associated with the test. For soybean variety evaluation tests, CV values less than 15% indicates that the precision of the test was good in distinguishing differences between varieties.

Return to Table of Contents


METHODS AND DEFINITIONS

Non Roundup Ready tests were evaluated in a randomized complete block experimental design and replicated three times. Roundup Ready test were evaluated in a group balanced block design and replicated three times. Row widths, number of rows planted and harvested, and length of row harvested are shown on the production information page. Harvest was as near the date of first harvest maturity as work schedules and weather would permit. Fertilizer was applied according to VPI & SU soil test recommendations. In the Roundup Ready tests, only roundup herbicide was applied to the herbicide resistant varieties. The non Roundup Ready varieties in this test received the appropriate herbicide to control the weeds present. All test were weed free.

Seeding Rates/Planting Populations (seeds/acre):

Maturity Group

Full Season

Double-Crop

III

180,000

--

IV

180,000

250,000

IV-S

160,000

230,000

V

160,000

230,000

VI

140,000

--

All locations had the above seeding rates, except for Orange and Warsaw Full Season Tests, which were sown at 160,000 seeds per acre.

Maturity Group 4S is a designation for varieties which are late maturing (or southern) in maturity group 4.

Yields were taken and adjusted to 13% moisture. A bushel weight of 60 pounds was used to determine bushel-per-acre (BU/AC) yield.

Maturity (MAT in DAYS) was taken at the date when 95% of the pods turned brown (R8).

Lodging (LOD) notes are recorded on a scale of 1 to 5 according to the following criteria:

1.0 - almost all plants erect
2.0 - either all plants leaning slightly, or a few plants down
3.0 - either all plants leaning moderately (45° angle), or 25 to 50% down
4.0 - either all plants leaning considerably, or 50 to 80% down
5.0 - all plants down

Plant Height (HT) is determined as the average length of plants in a plot from the ground to the uppermost node of the plant at maturity.

Seed Quality (SQ) is rated from 1 to 5 according to the following scale:
1.0 = very good; 2.0 = good; 3.0 = fair; 4.0 = poor; 5.0 = very poor.

Protein (PROT) and Oil percentage of harvested seed were calculated using a Pacific-Scientific NIR grain analyzer and were reported on a dry weight basis. The calculations were made by the USDA Analytical Chemistry Support Unit in Peoria, Illinois. In maturity groups IV and V, average protein and oil contents were determined from seed harvested at Painter, Suffolk, and Warsaw; for maturity group VI, protein and oil were determined from seed harvested at Painter and Suffolk.

Return to Table of Contents


PRODUCTION INFORMATION

 

Number of Rows

 

 

 

Location

Planting Date

 

Herbicides

Date
Applied

 

Insecticides

 

Soil Type

Row Width

Planted

Harvested

Length of Row Harvested

Blackstone-FS

May 14

Dual

Sencor

Basagram

5/14

5/16

6/11

None

Dothan Norfolk

18"

4

2

14’

Orange-FS RR

May 23

RR-Roundup

NRR-Storm,Assure

6/12

6/12

None

Davidson Clay Loam

30"

3

1

20'

Orange-FS

May 28

Dual

6/12

None

Davidson Clay Loam

30"

3

1

20’

Painter-FS RR

May 29

RR-Roundup

NRR-Storm, Poast Plus,

Basagram, Dash

6/18,7/3

6/18

7/3

None

Bojac SL

18"

4

2

14'

Painter-FS

May 29

Dual Sencor

5/30

None

Bojac SL

18"

4

2

14’

Painter-DC RR

June 30

Roundup

RR-Roundup

NRR-Storm,Poast Plus

7/2

8/12

8/12

None

Bojac SL

18"

4

2

14'

Painter-DC

June 30

Roundup, Dual,Lorox

Assure

7/2

8/16

None

Bojac SL

18"

4

2

14’

Suffolk-FS RR

May 19

RR-Roundup

NRR-Canopy, Dual

Storm

6/21

5/19

6/21

None

Lunchburg Fine Sandy Loam None

18"

4

2

14’

Suffolk-FS

May 12

Canopy, Dual, Basagram

5/16

6/11

None

Nansemond Fine Sandy Loam

18"

 

4

 

 

2

 

 

14’

Suffolk-DC RR

 

 

 

July 8

 

 

RR-Roundup

NRR-Roundup,Canopy, Dual

Classic,Assure

7/9

7/9

 

7/22

None

 

 

Lynchburg Fine Sandy Loam

 

18"

 

 

4

 

 

2

 

 

14'

 

 

Suffolk-DC

July 8

Canopy, Roundup Classic,Assure

7/9

7/22

None

DragstonFine Sandy Loam

18"

4

2

14’

Warsaw-FS RR

May 31

RR-Roundup

NRR-Assure, Storm

6/13

6/13

 

None

Kempsville Loam

30"

4

2

12’

Warsaw -FS

May 31

Prowl

Reflex, Fusilade DX

5/12

6/13

Dimeth oate

Kempsville Loam

30"

4

2

12'

Warsaw-DC RR

June 27

RR-Roundup

NRR-Poast Plus, Storm

7/28

7/28

None

Kempsville Loam

24"

4

2

12'

Warsaw DC

June 25

Dual, Roundup

6/26

None

Kempsville Loam

24"

4

2

12’

*FS = Full-Season, DC = Double-crop
RR = Roundup Ready, NRR = Non Roundup Ready

Return to Table of Contents


MONTHLY PRECIPITATION (INCHES) AND AVERAGE RAINFALL DURING MAY THROUGH OCTOBER AT VARIETY TEST LOCATIONS.

 

Location

May

June

July

Aug.

Sept.

Oct.

Total

Blackstone

1997

30-yr Avg.

1.01
3.42
3.39
3.67
4.09
5.49
1.30
4.02
2.79
3.57
3.69
2.71
16.27 22.88

Orange

1997

57-yr. Avg.

0.92
3.88
2.73
3.69
9.92
4.60
1.52
4.04
3.36
3.63
3.03
3.51
21.48
23.35

Painter

1997

57-yr Avg.

1.80
3.41
1.83
3.34
5.02
4.40
1.96
4.20
1.19
3.45
3.83
3.48
15.63
22.28

Suffolk

1997

65-yr. Avg.

2.54
3.79
0.69
4.20
10.58
5.88
1.24
5.78
1.99
4.11
2.89
3.40
19.93
27.16

Warsaw

1997

33-yr Avg.

1.89
4.47
2.51
3.67
5.79
4.25
2.32
4.11
1.41
4.08
2.44
3.34
16.36
23.92

The average rainfall was considerably higher than average at all locations this year.

Return to Table of Contents


SUPPLIERS OF SOYBEAN VARIETIES TESTED IN 1996

SUPPLIER

BRAND

VARIETY

Ag-Chem, Inc.

P. O. Box 2178

Salisbury, MD 21802

Dyna-Gro

DG3444n, DG3530n, UAPX 182,

UAPX 183

Asgrow Seed Company

2605 E. Kilgore Rd.

Kalamazoo, Mich.49002

Asgrow

AG3601, AG3701, AG4341, AG4501, AG4601, AG4701, A5545, AG5601

AgriPro Seeds Inc.

6075 Poplar, Suite 435

Memphis, TN 38137

Hyperformer

AgriPro

HY 574, AP 4880, AP 543 RR, AP 588RR

Caverndale Farms

1921 Bluegrass Rd.

Danville, KY 40422

Caverndale

Farm

CF 461, CF 492

Clemson University

Soybean Breeding Program

Clemson, SC 29634

Public

Musen, Dillion , SC 87-119

Dekalb Genetics Corp.

3100 Sycamore Rd.

Dekalb, IL 60115

DEKALB

CX 445,CX478, CX494,CX499C,CX510C, CX570C

Delta-King

13941 Gentito Rd.

Amelia, Virginia

Delta King

5961 RR

Delta & Pine Land Co.

P.O. box 157

Scott, MS 38772

Deltapine

Sure-Grow

DP 3478, DPS 9749, DP 3519S, DPS 9752, DP 3588, DP 5644 RR, DPX 5767RR, DPX 9757RR, SG 597RR, SG567RR

Hartz Seed

P. O. Box 946

Stuttgart, AR 72160

Hartz

H 4944 RR, H4994 RR, H5000 RR, H5181 RR, H5999 RR, H5545 RR, H5350 RR, H5855 RR, H6686 RR

Hoffman Seeds

144 Main Street

Landisville, PA 17538

Hoffman

Funk’s

NK

Funks 3505

Hoffman 7484

NK S42-K2, NK S46-W8

Illinois Foundation Seeds Inc.

P.O. box 722

Champaign, Il. 61820

Public

Iroquois

Macon

Montague Farms

Rt. 2 Box6

Center Cross, Va. 22437

Montague

Farms

MFS-553, MFS-591, MFL-552

Md. Crop Improv. Assoc.

50 Harry S. Truman Pkwy.

Annapolis, MD 21401

Public

Manokin, Bass, Wicomico, Md 92-5769

Mycogen Seeds

3600 N. Columbia

Plainview, Tx. 79072

Mycogen

470, 5430

Missouri Foundation Seed

3600 New Haven Road

Columbia, MS 65201

Public

Delsoy 5500, Magellan, Maverick, Mustang

N. C. Foundation Seed, Inc.

4025 Beryl Rd.

Raleigh, NC 27606

Public

Brim, Clifford, Graham, Holladay, Prolina

Ohio State University

Soybean Breeding Program

Wooster, OH 44691

Public

Charleston, Stressland

Pioneer Hi-Bred, Int'l, Inc.

435 E. Smith Ave.

Winterville, NC 28590

Pioneer

Variety

93B81, 93B51, 9395, 9396, 94B01, 9421, 9444, 9482, 94B41, 9492, 94B81, 9511, 9552, 95B71, 9584, 9594, 9631, 9671, 9692

Southern States Coop., Inc.

6606 West Broad Street

P. O. Box 26234

Richmond, VA 23260

Southern States

HT-381-STS, HT-527-STS, FFR-RT-386, FFR 396, FFR 439, FFR-RT-447, FFR-478, FFR-493, FFR-RT-540N, FFR-560, FFR-563, FFR-594, FFR-665, FFR-696, FFR-EXP 21683, FFR-EXP-24218, FFR-EXP-24595, FFR-EXP-24744, FFR-EXP-24644, FFR-EXP-24813, FFR-EXP-42113, FFR-45592FFR 45621, FFR45623, FFR-EXP-54065, FFR-EXP-54295, FFR-EXP-54326

Terra International, Inc.

600 4th St, P. O. Box 6000

Sioux, City, IA 51102-6000

Terra

Terra E387, TS 415, TS 474, Ts 4792,

TS 504

Va .Foundation Seed, Inc.

Box 78

Mt. Holly, VA 22524

Public

Accomac, Camp, Chesapeake, Hutcheson, York

VPI & SU, Agron. Dept.

Soybean Breeding Program

Agronomy Department

Blacksburg, VA 24061

Public

V88-494, V90-798, V90-1012, V91-2492,

V91-3036, V92-0163, V92-0254, V92-0386, V92-0840, V92-0847, V92-0974, V92-0995, V92-1333, V92-697, V93-1079, V93-1633, V93-2329, V93-3036, V93-3056, V93-3114, V93-3397,

University of Arkansas

115 Plant Science

Fayettevill, AR. 72701

Public

UARK-5896

University of Kentucky

Soybean Breeding Program

Lexington, KY 40546

Public

Calhoun

University of Tennessee

Soybean Breeding Program

Knoxville, TN 37901

Public

TN5-95, TN6-90

Return to Table of Contents


Disclaimer: Trade and brand names are used only for the purpose of information and the sponsors do not guarantee nor warrant the standards of the product, nor do they imply approval of the product to the exclusion of others which may also be suitable.

Virginia Cooperative Extension programs and employment are open to all, regardless of race, color, religion, sex, age, veteran status, national origin, disability, or political affiliation. An equal opportunity/affirmative action employer. Issued in furtherance of Cooperative Extension work, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Virginia State University, and the U. S. Department of Agriculture cooperating. C. Clark Jones, Director, Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg; Lorenza W. Lyons, Administrator, 1890 Extension Programs, Virginia State, Petersburg.